You are currently viewing solar panels east west roof

solar panels east west roof

  • Post author:
  • Post category:etc
  • Post comments:0 Comments

We all know about the recommendation that solar panels should be placed facing south for better utilization. If the configuration of the roof forces us to place the solar panels to the east or west, then we have limited options. What can we expect from this kind of solar panel setup? However, interest in installing photovoltaic systems on east-west roofs is constantly growing. Although they are south-oriented systems, better east-west-oriented PV systems can also bring significant profits. Moreover, the sharp drop in modulus prices is expected to drive increased demand for east-west systems in the future. From the perspective of network operators, solar panels facing east or west can work well.

East-West-facing solar panels can work well

Although south-oriented systems are a better option, east-west-oriented PV systems can also bring some profit. Moreover, due to the sharp decline, the demand for east-west systems also increased. Grid operators prefer east-west-oriented PV systems over south-oriented ones because they distribute energy more evenly throughout the day, reducing power peaks and relieving the network. Previously, it was assumed that PV systems oriented east-west required separate inverters for each orientation, or at least one inverter with multiple MPPs (maximum power point), to avoid mismatched losses. Most solar installers commonly use grid inverters to connect the solar panels in series with the electrical cable. A string refers to each group of panels connected in series. We connect each string to a separate input on the inverter. Often, in such cases, we connect several strings in parallel and then into one inverter input. To do this, each string must have the same number of panels and be of identical brands and models.

Connecting panels and inverters in a west-east configuration

If we put solar panels on the east and west parts of the roof, then we usually connect them separately and use two inputs into an inverter. However, under some circumstances, it is possible for east-west system solar panels to have a splitter on one input of the inverter. Why would SMP want to do this? Well, a single array inverter may be cheaper than a dual input inverter, or we may want to save the second input for the south-facing array if the roof configuration suits us. Any flat-roofed building, including large commercial installations, can also utilize racks to achieve the same result as houses with direct east- and west-facing roofs. The first scientific paper on this topic was published by engineer Dietmar Staudacher from the Fronius Institute in 2009. According to his work, the panels should be inclined as little as possible, around 24 degrees. We will verify this claim later with the SPAC application.

The Benefits Of An East-West Splitter

A few years ago, when solar panel prices were high, the best direction for the panels was south. So that they would produce the most electricity and make it possible to earn as much as possible. An east-west configuration can help us produce a stable amount of energy throughout the day. When the panels face south, they start producing energy in the morning, reach a maximum level at solar noon, and then decline during midday. With an east-west orientation, production should be stable with minor oscillations during the day. In order to see exactly what we gain and what we lose, we will perform an analysis using the SPAC application.

Analysis of the west-east system using the SPAC application

To analyze this case, I will use the SPAC application for Europe, which is available at the link www.wind.in.rs/solareu. I will choose the city or area of Munich in Germany. The choice is random; I wanted it to be a city in the central part of Europe.

We have to set up parameters. 

Other parameters are: tile angle: 40 degrees.

Orientation (we will take into account two cases):

 Case 1: 0 degrees, totally oriented to the south

Case 2: 90 degrees of orientation towards the east (or 0 degrees of orientation towards the west; the result is the same). Let’s choose the option of panels on the ground. We must check this option so that the result of the calculation is correct.

A total of 10 pieces from the manufacturer, Canadan Solar CS3N-395 with a power of 385 W, are in the format of 10 pieces in one row. The choice of panels does not affect the analysis because our goal is to calculate the daily energy gain per unit area (kW/m2). We must check this option so that the result of the calculation is correct. Pressing the “Calculate” button yields the results once all the data has been entered correctly.  

Parameters set for analysis

In a bunch of tables with various data that we get during the calculation, we will focus on the most important: “All components of solar radiation depend on the incident angle.” In that table, there are gains from radiation: direct, diffuse, and reflected, and their sum for each hour in the average day of the month of the year. The average day of the month in the year is adopted as the 15th.

 

South (left) and East (right) tables

The data confirms our expectations. The east-facing panel starts with maximum operation at sunrise and reaches its maximum at 10 o’clock. After that, it falls, and around 11 p.m., south-facing panels reach it. Depending on the time of year, the direct radiation component disappears around 3 p.m. However, the diffuse and reflected components are still present. The panels continue to operate until the end of the day. With south-oriented panels, as expected, its irradiation increases after morning awakening and overtakes east-oriented panels definitively by 11 a.m., reaching its maximum capacity and slowly decreasing. The following table and diagram show this (uneven) race in solar energy production. 

Data 3 cases : January, April and July ( south and east-facing solar panels)
Chart January, April , July: south and east-facing solar panels

If we make the superposition east and south facing equal numbers of panels, we will get a diagram almost identical to the south-facing panels only.

Superposition of East and West-Faced Solar Panels

The next important analysis table that we see after a little scrolling is total energy gain per unit area (kWh/m2/day).  After comparing the results for the eastern and southern panels, we get that in this case, the south-oriented panel is better on average for the whole year by about 26%. And finally, let’s check the claim of engineer Dietmar Staudacher that the panels should have as little slope as possible.

Let’s go back to the beginning of the SPAC application. Leave all the parameters the same except for the slope, which we will set to 20 degrees. After the calculation, we get a bulky table, which we will skip and stick only to the table for average daily gains. The calculation results show that the difference dropped to 17%. On table bellow is calculation for 40 degree slope.

Average monthly production 40 degree slope

FACING Jan Feb Mar Apr May June Jule Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
South 112.82 167.35 255.68 323.95 375.15 364.51 413.81 402.29 301.91 213.00 108.88 77.11
East 43.90 80.60 156.73 242.83 324.01 331.40 367.47 323.14 200.35 111.82 45.63 28.50
% 61.09 51.84 38.70 25.04 13.63 9.08 11.20 19.67 33.64 47.50 58.09 63.04

Conclusion

If the situation with our house or roof is such that the orientation is west-east, we can still install solar panels. The investment will be twice as much, and the loss will depend on the angle of the setting, preferably as small as possible. We have to count on a loss of 27%. We will have electricity from morning until dark, which is convenient if we need a constant flow of electricity without peaks. The electric distribution company will also be happy about our venture because they also like a constant flow of electricity without peaks. At a time when the prices of solar panels are falling, we should take a good look at what we have and then calculate what we can get.

mmitic

Mechanikal engineer and php programer, work in electric power industry more then25 years

Leave a Reply